3 reasons why Gautam Gambhir was right to drop Mohammed Siraj for 1st New Zealand Test

India head coach Gautam Gambhir and captain Shubman Gill made a bold selection call by leaving Mohammed Siraj out of the playing XI for the first Test against New Zealand at the Basin Reserve in Wellington on Thursday. India opted for four specialist pacers after winning the toss and choosing to bowl.
Siraj's omission came despite his experience and strong record in overseas conditions. He featured only in the fifth ODI of India's New Zealand tour, taking two wickets and helping secure a 22-run victory. However, his recent Test returns and workload gave the team management reasons to consider other options.
Mohammed Siraj's recent performances in major Test series made his omission easier to understand. Although he has been a dependable overseas bowler, his economy rates in Australia and England were relatively high.
During the 2024–25 Border-Gavaskar Trophy in Australia, Siraj bowled 157.1 overs across five Tests and claimed 20 wickets at an average of 31.15. He finished without taking a five-wicket haul.
During the 2025 Anderson-Tendulkar Trophy in England, Mohammed Siraj finished as the leading wicket-taker, with 23 wickets in five Tests and 185.3 overs, including 6/70 at Edgbaston. However, he averaged 32.43 and conceded runs at 4.02 per over. Bumrah averaged 26.00 at an economy rate of 3.04.
Siraj was India's only fast bowler to feature in all five Tests in England and bowled heavily across the Australian tour and home series against West Indies and South Africa. He claimed 78 wickets in 23 Tests across 2024 and 2025, bowling more Test overs than almost any fast bowler globally during that period.
Across three Tests against Afghanistan and Sri Lanka in 2026, Siraj took only five wickets in 57 overs at an average of 28.60. His pace visibly dropped in Sri Lanka. He also returned figures of 1/187 in 41 overs in the 2026–27 Duleep Trophy final and conceded 118 runs for four wickets in 35 overs against New Zealand A.
The Wellington surface had a thick grass covering and moisture underneath. Anshul Kamboj offered India a disciplined option with his upright seam position and ability to hit a consistent fourth-stump line.
Prasidh Krishna also brought a different skill set to the attack. His height and high release point allowed him to extract bounce, making him a useful option as the surface dried and became harder. India could use him as a hit-the-deck bowler.
Tom Latham, Devon Conway, Henry Nicholls and Rachin Ravindra made up the hosts' first four batting positions. Mohammed Siraj has tended to concede runs against left-handers while searching for wickets.
Akash Deep, meanwhile, offered a more disciplined approach around the off-stump channel. His fuller lengths could force the left-handers to play more deliveries and build pressure alongside Bumrah.
India left Ravindra Jadeja out and selected Washington Sundar as the spin-bowling all-rounder. With four specialist fast bowlers in the side, India needed contributions from positions eight and nine, which favoured Akash Deep and Anshul Kamboj over Mohammed Siraj.
Mohammed Siraj has a Test batting average of just 5.05 across 65 innings, with 192 runs and a highest score of 22. He generally bats at number 10 or 11 and offers limited resistance against short-pitched bowling.
Akash Deep has a stronger batting record, scoring 163 runs in 15 Test innings at an average of 11.64. Kamboj offers further depth with 782 runs in 60 first-class innings at an average of 15.03. His highest score is 60, and he has two first-class half-centuries and 41 sixes.
With Dhruv Jurel at number seven, Akash Deep at number eight and Kamboj at number nine, India had batting options before Bumrah came in at number 10. Both replacements had scored first-class half-centuries and offered greater resistance than Siraj with the bat.
Also read: Watch: Shubman Gill clashes with umpires after Glenn Phillips' DRS confusion in 1st IND vs NZ Test
Share this article:
Comments
Loading comments...
Related Articles

Hasan Mahmud ruled out of 2nd Test vs South Africa, replacement named
Ahead of the second Test match against the South Africa National Cricket Team, Bangladesh is dealing with uncertainty over Hasan Mahmud's availability. Mahmud did significantly well in the previous match of the ongoing Test series, taking four wickets.Amid his ongoing form, the Bangladesh National Cricket Team was hopeful to keep Hasan Mahmud in their playing eleven for the next match, starting on November 23 at the SuperSport Park Cricket Stadium in Centurion. But an issue with his tennis elbow...

"Very slim chance": Wasim Jaffer makes big statement on India's WTC final qualification hopes
The India National Cricket Team is currently in New Zealand for a two-match Test series. The first Test match has already started on Thursday, November 19th at the Basin Reserve, Wellington. Amidst this, former India opener Wasim Jaffer stated that there is very little chance for the Men in Blue to qualify for the ICC World Test Championship (WTC) 2025-2027 final.This is a crucial series for the side, keeping in mind that the Men in Blue have to win six Test matches out of their remaining seven,...

Harsh Dubey confident of making India Test debut in 2027 Border-Gavaskar Trophy
While the Indian team management handed multiple bowlers their debut cap for the Test format, spinner Harsh Dubey is yet to get his Test cap for the India National Cricket Team. Amid his fine form in domestic cricket, Dubey is hopeful to represent the national team soon in the format.Harsh Dubey has so far played only two matches for India in the One Day International format, but has yet to play his first match for the team in the other two formats. Like many players, Dubey is also nurturing his...
