5 most controversial moments in Ashes history

Published - 19 Nov 2025, 17:29 IST | Updated - 19 Nov 2025, 17:32 IST

England and Australia are set to renew their iconic rivalry in the upcoming Ashes series, beginning with the first Test in Perth on November 21. While Australia enter as favourites, their injury concerns give England renewed belief heading into the contest. Across decades of competition, the Ashes has delivered not only unforgettable cricketing brilliance but also several explosive controversies. Here, we look at five of the most controversial moments in Ashes history.

During the 1979–80 Test at Perth, Australian legend Dennis Lillee walked out to bat wielding an aluminium bat made by a company owned by his friend. With no rules at the time prohibiting metal bats, Lillee used it freely until England captain Mike Brearley protested, arguing the bat was damaging the ball. After discussions, umpires asked Lillee to switch bats. Lillee furiously resisted until captain Greg Chappell intervened, convincing him to change. Lillee then threw the aluminium bat away in anger—creating one of cricket’s most bizarre controversies.

In one of modern cricket’s most heated Ashes flashpoints, Jonny Bairstow was controversially stumped by Alex Carey after wandering out of his crease at the end of an over. Carey collected the ball from a bouncer and immediately threw it at the stumps, with Bairstow assuming the ball was dead. The third umpire confirmed the dismissal was legal. The incident ignited furious debates about the “spirit of cricket” and triggered a chorus of boos at Lord’s, leading to tense scenes both on and off the field.

Michael Clarke’s infamous stump-mic warning, “Get ready for a broken f**ing arm”*, directed at James Anderson during the opening Test at Brisbane remains one of the most shocking on-field exchanges in Ashes history. The remark, made during a tense final spell, dominated headlines worldwide. The moment reignited debates about sledging limits and set the tone for one of the most fiery and hostile Ashes series ever played.

Just 19 days before the 2021–22 Ashes, Australian cricket was shaken when captain Tim Paine stepped down after explicit text messages he sent to a female colleague in 2017 resurfaced. Though previously investigated, the controversy re-emerged publicly, prompting Paine’s resignation. The scandal overshadowed the lead-up to the series and raised questions about leadership accountability and Cricket Australia's handling of the incident.

In the 2013 Ashes epic at Trent Bridge, Stuart Broad edged Ashton Agar to Michael Clarke at slip via Brad Haddin’s gloves. The deflection was clear, yet umpire Aleem Dar gave Broad not out. Broad, knowing he had edged it, chose not to walk and remained at the crease. He went on to score a crucial 65, and England won the match by just 14 runs. The incident sparked widespread debate about sportsmanship and the decision review system, becoming one of the series’ defining controversies.