Ashes 2025-26 : Mitchell Starc loses cool and demands ‘sacking’ of snicko technology after Jamie Smith incident on Day 2 of Adelaide Test

Table of Contents
The Ashes 2025-26 series in Adelaide was plunged into chaos on Day 2 as technical glitches and inconsistent umpiring decisions ignited a fierce debate over the future of the Decision Review System (DRS). The flashpoint occurred during the morning session of the third Test, where a series of contradictory Snicko readings left both teams fuming and prompted a blunt assessment from veteran Australian pacer Mitchell Starc.
The reliability of “Snickometer” technology reached its breaking point on Thursday after two separate incidents involving England wicketkeeper-batter Jamie Smith exposed deep flaws in the system’s calibration. In the first instance, a sharp short ball from Pat Cummins appeared to brush Smith’s glove before popping up to Usman Khawaja at first slip; however, despite replays showing the glove ripple, Snicko remained entirely flat, leading third umpire Chris Gaffaney to rule it as a helmet-strike. In a baffling reversal of luck just two overs later, Smith was given out caught-behind after attempting a pull shot, even though slow-motion replays showed a visible gap between bat and ball.
Frustrated by a sequence of events that saw a visible glove-impact ignored by the audio graph, Starc was captured on the stump microphone delivering a scathing verdict: “Snicko needs to be sacked. That’s the worst technology there is… they made a mistake the other day and made another today.” His outburst highlighted a growing lack of confidence in the technology, which had already been under fire after a high-profile error on Day 1 that allowed Alex Carey to escape a clear edge and go on to score a match-defining century.
This time, the Snicko graph produced a spike a full frame after the ball had passed the bat, which Gaffaney deemed sufficient evidence to uphold the dismissal. The England camp, led by a visibly fuming captain Ben Stokes, was left in disbelief as they watched their batter trudge off to a decision that defied the naked eye.
Also WATCH: Ashes 2025-26: Glenn McGrath’s reaction breaks the internet as Nathan Lyon surpasses him on Australia’s all-time wicket-taker list | Adelaide Test, Day 2
Australia’s vice-like grip on the Ashes tightened significantly on Day 2 in Adelaide as England’s batting lineup crumbled under relentless pressure from a rejuvenated home attack. Resuming at 326/8, Australia added a vital 45 runs to reach a final total of 371, headlined by Starc’s aggressive 54 and Jofra Archer’s spirited 5/53.
England’s response was immediate and disastrous, as they plummeted to 42/3 before lunch, with Nathan Lyon removing Ben Duckett (29) and Ollie Pope (3) in a single historic over to surpass Glenn McGrath on the all-time wickets list. Pat Cummins, returning from injury with figures of 3/54, claimed the prize scalp of Joe Root for just 19, while Harry Brook’s defiant 45 was cut short by a tactical masterstroke from Cameron Green.
A late-order collapse saw the visitors slide from 159/5 to a precarious 168/8 as Scott Boland (2/31) dismantled the tail with surgical precision. Only a gritty, unbeaten 55-run partnership between captain Stokes (45* off 151 balls) and Archer (30*) prevented a complete capitulation, guiding England to 213/8 at stumps. Despite this rearguard action, the tourists remain a massive 158 runs behind with just 2 wickets in hand, facing the daunting reality that Australia needs only a few more sessions to effectively retain the urn.
Also READ: Adelaide Test: Pat Cummins and Nathan Lyon put Australia on top with early wickets on Day 2 – Ashes 2025/26
Share this article:
Comments
Loading comments...
Related Articles

"Very slim chance": Wasim Jaffer makes big statement on India's WTC final qualification hopes
The India National Cricket Team is currently in New Zealand for a two-match Test series. The first Test match has already started on Thursday, November 19th at the Basin Reserve, Wellington. Amidst this, former India opener Wasim Jaffer stated that there is very little chance for the Men in Blue to qualify for the ICC World Test Championship (WTC) 2025-2027 final.This is a crucial series for the side, keeping in mind that the Men in Blue have to win six Test matches out of their remaining seven,...

Harsh Dubey confident of making India Test debut in 2027 Border-Gavaskar Trophy
While the Indian team management handed multiple bowlers their debut cap for the Test format, spinner Harsh Dubey is yet to get his Test cap for the India National Cricket Team. Amid his fine form in domestic cricket, Dubey is hopeful to represent the national team soon in the format.Harsh Dubey has so far played only two matches for India in the One Day International format, but has yet to play his first match for the team in the other two formats. Like many players, Dubey is also nurturing his...
Nepal vs Bangladesh historic T20I to be played at Lord's in June 2027
Lord's will host a T20 International between Nepal and Bangladesh on June 3, 2027, part of an MCC-hosted Nepal tour of England.
