Ashes 2025-26: Sunil Gavaskar takes swipe at ICC over pitch ratings after Melbourne Test ends in two days

Table of Contents
Former India captain Sunil Gavaskar has once again stirred debate around pitch assessments by openly questioning the International Cricket Council (ICC). The batting great has highlighted what he believes are double standards in the way pitch ratings are awarded, using the recently concluded fourth Ashes Test at the Melbourne Cricket Ground as a prime example.
The Melbourne Test raised eyebrows after it wrapped up inside just two days, with bowlers dominating from the very first session. A staggering 20 wickets fell on Day 1 — the highest number in Australia on an opening day since 1951 — followed by another 16 on Day 2. In total, the match was completed in just 142 overs, an unusually short duration for a Test match at one of cricket’s most iconic venues.
Despite the heavy assistance for bowlers, Gavaskar feels the pitch is unlikely to attract criticism from match officials. Drawing comparisons with the opening Test of the series in Perth, which also ended inside two days yet received a glowing assessment, the former opener suggested that the MCG surface could still escape scrutiny.
Gavaskar pointed out that the Perth Test pitch was rated ‘very good’ despite similar conditions leading to a rapid finish. He added a sarcastic twist by suggesting that the rating for the Melbourne pitch may depend more on who is holding the referee’s clipboard than on the actual nature of the surface.
Gavaskar noted that with Jeff Crowe officiating the Melbourne and Sydney Tests instead of Ranjan Madugalle, the wording of the rating could conveniently change. According to him, the removal of the word “very” from “very good” might be the only visible difference, even though more wickets fell in Melbourne than in Perth.
“Since there is a new match referee, Jeff Crowe, for the Melbourne and Sydney Test matches, the rating could be different. Since 36 wickets fell in the Melbourne Test instead of 32 in Perth, Crowe might drop the word ‘very’ from the ‘very good’ that Madugalle gave for the Perth pitch and rate the MCG pitch as good. Surprises never cease, of course, so we may get another rating,” Gavaskar wrote in his column for Sportstar.
Also READ: “I was in a state of shock”: MCG curator breaks silence after farce of two-day Boxing Day Test – Ashes 2025-26
The 75-year-old did not stop there. He also took a dig at how Indian pitch curators are often portrayed by ICC match referees. Gavaskar sarcastically remarked that while curators in Australia may make an occasional “human error,” they are rarely labeled as manipulative — a stark contrast to the harsh language often used for Indian groundsmen.
“The curators, or as we found out about the person in charge at the MCG, the Director of Turf, may make a human error and get it slightly wrong, but they are not as devious as those ‘horrible groundsmen’ in India who do not even prepare a pitch and expect the batters to score runs on them. Tut tut,” Gavaskar added.
Also READ: Ashes 2025-26: Ben Stokes and Steve Smith slam MCG pitch after 4th Test ends in two days
Share this article:
Comments
Loading comments...
Related Articles

Sunil Gavaskar slams India's decision to pick Washington Sundar ahead of Ravindra Jadeja in 1st Test
Former India captain Sunil Gavaskar questioned the decision to leave Ravindra Jadeja out of the playing XI for the first Test against New Zealand. Gavaskar criticised the selection of Washington Sundar as the visitors' only spinner, describing the all-rounder as 'rusty' due to his lack of recent match time.India captain Shubman Gill had confirmed before the series opener that the team would play only one spinner alongside four specialist fast bowlers at the Basin Reserve in Wellington. New Zeala...

Henry Thornton set to make T20I debut as Australia announce updated squad for England series
The Australia National Cricket Team has made some interesting changes to their squad for the upcoming five-match T20I series against England, which will begin in Melbourne on November 21. Fast bowler Henry Thornton has received his maiden call-up to Australia’s T20I squad.The 29-year-old pacer could make his international debut during the upcoming five-match T20I series between Australia and England. The hosts would be aiming to make a strong comeback in the T20I series after losing the ODI seri...

Kane Williamson names next-gen 'Fab Four', includes Shubman Gill and Yashasvi Jaiswal
The fans of the current generation have witnessed some of the greatest cricketers over the recent period of time. Monkier has been given by fans termed as 'Fab Four', which describes the four cricketers Virat Kohli, Steve Smith, Joe Root and Kane Williamson, who competed against each other. Now Kane Williamson has termed the next generation 'Fab Four.'Kane Williamson recently released his autobiography, 'The Bare Margins'. He has been one of the finest cricketers of this generation, and the form...
