ENG vs IND 2025: Karun Nair is not a No. 3 player in my book - Sanjay Manjrekar
Published - 09 Jul 2025, 22:25 IST | Updated - 09 Jul 2025, 22:39 IST
Sanjay Manjrekar feels that Sai Sudharsan should bat at No. 3 in the upcoming third Test between India and England in the Anderson-Tendulkar Trophy 2025 at the Lord's Cricket Ground in London, which starts on Thursday, July 10.
Sudharsan made his Test debut in the series opener at Headingley. However, the youngster didn't have a memorable start to his career in the longest format, registering scores of 0 and 30, batting at No. 3. Karun Nair made a comeback in the Indian Test team after eight years in the same Test and batted at No. 6. He scored 0 and 20 in the two innings, respectively.
In the second Test at Edgbaston, Sudharsan was dropped and Nair was promoted to No. 3. The right-handed batter scored 31 in the first innings and 26 in the second. Manjrekar mentioned that he wouldn't have left Sudharsan out of the playing XI after just one game.
"There were some very interesting selections made in the last game which I didn't agree with. In the end a win can put a cover on those decisions. I thought Sai Sudharsan, after just one match, to be left out considering he is a young player that we are looking at the future. He played pretty okay in the second innings. I'd like to stick with him but this team management is not afraid to chop and change depending on the vibe," he said on ESPN Cricinfo.
Manjrekar went on to mention that Nair is not a proper No. 3 batter. The cricketer-turned-commentator urged the Indian team management to bring Sudharsan back in the lineup and have him bat at No. 3 at the Home of Cricket.
"But I would like to see Sai Sudharsan at number three. Karun Nair is not a No. 3 player in my book. It is unfair to drop him after one Test if everyone is getting big hundreds. I think Sai deserves that opportunity as well," he added.
England have brought Jofra Archer into their playing XI for the third Test in place of Josh Tongue. The 30-year-old is set to play a Test match after four years. Manjrekar advised the Indian team to be careful with their batting, mentioning that Shubman Gill's scoring big in both innings of the Edgbaston Test overshadowed a lot of issues.
Pant reacts to ENG's possible game plan change at Lord's
"I'd like to see India being pragmatic and realistic about how good the team is. They've got to still be careful about their batting. Shubman Gill got these big hundreds and made sure that India could win the Test match. I'm just imagining him getting 103 and 104, and it would have been tough to win the Test. He has taken care of a lot of those issues. India need to make sure that the batting is in place. Perhaps a changed England attack will have more sharpness and potency," Sanjay Manjrekar reflected.
Share this article:
Comments
Loading comments...
Related Articles

'Steve Smith is a national hero': Moises Henriques weighs in on Sandpapergate scandal
The Sandpapergate Scandal, reignited by former Australia National Cricket Team opener Usman Khawaja, has stirred the world of cricket, as every former cricketer and coach has their say on the matter. The latest to comment was former Aussie all-rounder Moises Henriques, the current Portugal cricket captain, who backed former captain Steve Smith and called him a hero.Usman Khawaja reignited the darkest chapter of Cricket Australia history, ahead of his autobiography named Sabr release. He stated t...

Mitchell Marsh mentally affected by Cameron Bancroft's Sandpapergate claims, nearly pulled out of England ODI
The renewed Sandpapergate controversy reportedly took a personal toll on Australia captain Mitchell Marsh, who nearly withdrew from the third ODI against England in Hobart. According to a report by CODE Sports journalist Daniel Cherny, Marsh seriously considered missing the match as Cameron Bancroft prepared to publish his detailed account of the 2018 ball-tampering scandal.Mitchell Marsh eventually played in the series finale on November 18, but did not attend the post-match press conference af...
'Absolutely shocking' – Wasim Jaffer says India missed Mohammed Siraj on Day 1
Former India batter Wasim Jaffer criticises the omission of Mohammed Siraj from the playing XI in the opening Test against New Zealand at Basin Reserve, Wellington.
