Snicko controversy: Alex Carey responds after operator acknowledges ‘human error’ on Day 1 of Adelaide Test | Ashes 2025-26

Table of Contents
Alex Carey delivered a memorable performance on Day 1 of the 3rd Ashes Test in Adelaide, scoring a brilliant counter-attacking 106 to swing momentum back in Australia’s favour after an early batting collapse. The wicketkeeper’s innings not only revived the hosts but also became the centre of a major DRS controversy that sparked debate late into the day.
Coming in with Australia under pressure, Carey showed composure and intent, combining sharp strokeplay with calculated aggression. His century proved pivotal in stabilising the innings and frustrating England’s bowlers on a day that otherwise belonged to the visitors early on.
Carey’s knock, however, was not without controversy. During his innings, England appealed for a caught-behind dismissal after a delivery from Josh Tongue, with wicketkeeper Jamie Smith also convinced there was an edge. On-field umpire Ahsan Raza turned down the appeal, prompting England to opt for a review.
While Snicko showed a faint sound, the third umpire ruled that the ball had not passed close enough to the bat to confirm an edge. As a result, Carey was given a reprieve – a decision that left England visibly frustrated.
Controversy in #TheAshes as human error with Snicko saves Alex Carey… and his century 👀
— Cricket on TNT Sports (@cricketontnt) December 17, 2025
The debate intensified after Carey’s post-day press conference, where the Australian admitted that he had indeed made contact with the ball on the disputed delivery.
“I thought there was a bit of a feather or some sort of noise when it passed the bat,” Carey said. “If I was given out, I think I would have reviewed it. Probably not confidently though. It was a nice sound as it went past the bat.”
Carey’s candid admission added fuel to discussions around the accuracy and reliability of the Decision Review System in high-stakes Test matches.
Technology provider BBG Sports, which operates the Snickometer system, later acknowledged that a human error was responsible for the incorrect decision. In a statement issued to BBC Sport, the company explained that the wrong stump microphone had been selected during audio processing.
“Given that Alex Carey admitted he had hit the ball in question, the only conclusion that can be drawn is that the Snicko operator at the time selected the incorrect stump mic,” the statement read. “In light of this, BBG Sports takes full responsibility for the error.”
Also READ: Ashes 2025/26 – Fans erupt as Alex Carey lights up Adelaide Oval with magnificent ton on Day 1 of third Test
The microphone used was reportedly from the non-striker’s end, leading to inaccurate audio interpretation.
The incident has once again brought DRS protocols under the microscope, particularly in World Test Championship (WTC) matches where the system is mandatory. For the Adelaide Test, the review technology was supplied by the host broadcaster, Fox Cricket, as per ICC regulations.
While the error did not violate playing conditions, it raised concerns about operational checks and the margin for error in crucial moments of elite cricket.
Also WATCH: Zak Crawley takes a one-handed blinder to dismiss Travis Head on Day 1 of Adelaide Test
Share this article:
Comments
Loading comments...
Related Articles

'Steve Smith is a national hero': Moises Henriques weighs in on Sandpapergate scandal
The Sandpapergate Scandal, reignited by former Australia National Cricket Team opener Usman Khawaja, has stirred the world of cricket, as every former cricketer and coach has their say on the matter. The latest to comment was former Aussie all-rounder Moises Henriques, the current Portugal cricket captain, who backed former captain Steve Smith and called him a hero.Usman Khawaja reignited the darkest chapter of Cricket Australia history, ahead of his autobiography named Sabr release. He stated t...

Mitchell Marsh mentally affected by Cameron Bancroft's Sandpapergate claims, nearly pulled out of England ODI
The renewed Sandpapergate controversy reportedly took a personal toll on Australia captain Mitchell Marsh, who nearly withdrew from the third ODI against England in Hobart. According to a report by CODE Sports journalist Daniel Cherny, Marsh seriously considered missing the match as Cameron Bancroft prepared to publish his detailed account of the 2018 ball-tampering scandal.Mitchell Marsh eventually played in the series finale on November 18, but did not attend the post-match press conference af...
'Absolutely shocking' – Wasim Jaffer says India missed Mohammed Siraj on Day 1
Former India batter Wasim Jaffer criticises the omission of Mohammed Siraj from the playing XI in the opening Test against New Zealand at Basin Reserve, Wellington.
