‘What has he achieved as a batter’: R Ashwin raises doubts over Ben Stokes’ legacy ahead of ENG vs IND Lord’s Test

Table of Contents
India‘s legendary spinner Ravichandran Ashwin has launched a scathing critique of Ben Stokes’ batting performance in the Edgbaston Test and questioned England’s Test match approach under his leadership. Ashwin didn’t mince words as he analyzed Stokes’ shot selection, body mechanics, and decision-making in the second innings collapse, which saw England fold for 271 while chasing a massive 608-run target.
Speaking on his Hindi YouTube show ‘Ash Ki Baat’, the veteran off-spinner admitted admiration for Stokes but challenged his overall body of work in red-ball cricket. Ashwin began by acknowledging Stokes’ talent and past achievements, particularly his legendary 135 at Headingley in the 2019 Ashes. However, Ashwin raised valid question about Stokes’ consistency as a Test batter. He implied that outside of one iconic knock, Stokes has underwhelmed with the bat, especially in high-pressure scenarios.
“Ben Stokes is a fabulous player. I take my hat off to him. But we need to remember one thing, barring that Headingley heroics in the Ashes, what has he achieved as a batter?,” Ashwin said.
Ashwin also criticized England’s decision to chase 608 runs on the final day, calling it an act of ‘mockery.’ Ashwin further blamed England’s ‘brand loyalty’ to Bazball. He points out that rain was forecast, and drawing the match was realistic and valuable. But instead of adapting, England forced their attacking game plan, leading to needless wickets. His message: being aggressive is fine, but failing to adapt is poor leadership and poor cricket sense.
“You are batting at the stroke of lunch, final day of the Test match. ‘We will go for 608 runs’, this is nothing but absolute hara-kiri and mockery. You can’t go for 608 runs, boss. You’ve got the rain, and the only thing you needed was to draw the match. But you want to stay true to your style of play. That particular instinct to hit the ball is costing you these small dismissals,” the former Indian cricketer added.
Also READ: ENG vs IND 2025: Lord’s Weather Forecast for the third Test | England vs India
Ashwin provided a detailed technical breakdown of Stokes’ second innings dismissal against Washington Sundar, accusing the England captain of applying white-ball instincts in red-ball cricket.
“Go and check Ben Stokes’ dismissal against Washington Sundar. The ball drifted beautifully, it came on nicely, and I accept all these things, but just notice one thing. Washy’s release is from wide of the crease. He has released it from the corner. Now look at Ben Stokes’ head position, it’s coinciding with Rishabh Pant’s head. He played the line where Washington Sundar released the ball,” the legendary off-spinner stated.
Ashwin further explained that Stokes’ stance was that of someone playing a T20 shot, not a Test match stroke.
“Look at his foot. His leg is completely straight like an arrow. There is no bend in the knees. The leg stays straight only if you are looking to tonk the ball. In T20 or white-ball cricket, you pick the first line delivered from the hand, because there’s no drift. But in Test cricket, that method will expose you,” Ashwin concluded.
The third Test of the Anderson-Tendulkar Trophy begins Thursday, July 10 at the iconic Lord’s Cricket Ground. With the series tied at 1-1, the spotlight is firmly on England’s response and whether Stokes can answer his critics with the bat.
Also READ: ENG vs IND: Gus Atkinson IN? Karun Nair OUT? Here’s probable playing XI of both teams for the Lord’s Test
Share this article:
Comments
Loading comments...
Related Articles

'Steve Smith is a national hero': Moises Henriques weighs in on Sandpapergate scandal
The Sandpapergate Scandal, reignited by former Australia National Cricket Team opener Usman Khawaja, has stirred the world of cricket, as every former cricketer and coach has their say on the matter. The latest to comment was former Aussie all-rounder Moises Henriques, the current Portugal cricket captain, who backed former captain Steve Smith and called him a hero.Usman Khawaja reignited the darkest chapter of Cricket Australia history, ahead of his autobiography named Sabr release. He stated t...

Mitchell Marsh mentally affected by Cameron Bancroft's Sandpapergate claims, nearly pulled out of England ODI
The renewed Sandpapergate controversy reportedly took a personal toll on Australia captain Mitchell Marsh, who nearly withdrew from the third ODI against England in Hobart. According to a report by CODE Sports journalist Daniel Cherny, Marsh seriously considered missing the match as Cameron Bancroft prepared to publish his detailed account of the 2018 ball-tampering scandal.Mitchell Marsh eventually played in the series finale on November 18, but did not attend the post-match press conference af...
'Absolutely shocking' – Wasim Jaffer says India missed Mohammed Siraj on Day 1
Former India batter Wasim Jaffer criticises the omission of Mohammed Siraj from the playing XI in the opening Test against New Zealand at Basin Reserve, Wellington.
